Sunday, September 12, 2010

Paper: Global Warming analogous to many prior False Alarms

A paper in process examines the global warming alarmist movement and finds 26 other analogous false alarms that were endorsed by scientists, politicians, and the media. In each case, the analogous alarms were presented as “scientific,” but none were based on scientific forecasting procedures. Every alarming forecast proved to be false; the predicted adverse effects either did not occur or were minor. However, costly government policies remained in place long after the predicted disasters failed to materialize. The authors find the current global warming alarm is simply the latest example of a common social phenomenon: an alarm based on unscientific forecasts of a calamity. They conclude that the global warming alarm will fade, but not before much additional harm is done by governments and individuals making inferior decisions on the basis of unscientific forecasts.


Effects and outcomes of the global warming alarm: A forecasting project using the structured analogies method
Kesten C. Green
International Graduate School of Business, University of South Australia
J. Scott Armstrong
The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania
 
 
ABSTRACT: We summarize evidence showing that the global warming alarm movement has more of the character of a political movement than that of a scientific controversy. We then make forecasts of the effects and outcomes of this movement using a structured analysis of analogous situations—a method that has been shown to produce accurate forecasts for conflict situations. This paper summarizes the current status of this “structured analogies project.”
        We searched the literature and asked diverse experts to identify phenomena that could be characterized as alarms warning of future disasters that were endorsed by scientists, politicians, and the media, and that were accompanied by calls for strong action. The search yielded 71 possible analogies. We examined objective accounts to screen the possible analogies and found that 26 met all criteria. We coded each for forecasting procedures used, the accuracy of the forecasts, the types of actions called for, and the effects of actions implemented.
        Our preliminary findings are that analogous alarms were presented as “scientific,” but none were based on scientific forecasting procedures. Every alarming forecast proved to be false; the predicted adverse effects either did not occur or were minor. Costly government policies remained in place long after the predicted disasters failed to materialize. The government policies failed to prevent ill effects.
        The findings appear to be insensitive to which analogies are included. The structured analogies approach suggests that the current global warming alarm is simply the latest example of a common social phenomenon: an alarm based on unscientific forecasts of a calamity. We conclude that the global warming alarm will fade, but not before much additional harm is done by governments and individuals making inferior decisions on the basis of unscientific forecasts.

Exhibit 1: Analogies to the alarm over dangerous manmade global warming

Analogy & Year

1 Population growth and famine (Malthus) 1798

2 Timber famine economic threat 1865

3 Uncontrolled reproduction and degeneration (Eugenics) 1883

4 Lead in petrol and brain and organ damage 1928

5 Soil erosion agricultural production threat 1934

6 Asbestos and lung disease 1939

7 Fluoride in drinking water health effects 1945

8 DDT and cancer 1962

9 Population growth and famine (Ehrlich) 1968

10 Global cooling; through to 1975 1970

11 Supersonic airliners, the ozone hole, and skin cancer, etc. 1970


12 Environmental tobacco smoke health effects 1971

13 Population growth and famine (Meadows) 1972

14 Industrial production and acid rain 1974

15 Organophosphate pesticide poisoning 1976

16 Electrical wiring and cancer, etc. 1979

17 CFCs, the ozone hole, and skin cancer, etc. 1985

18 Listeria in cheese 1985

19 Radon in homes and lung cancer 1985

20 Salmonella in eggs 1988

21 Environmental toxins and breast cancer 1990

22 Mad cow disease (BSE) 1996

23 Dioxin in Belgian poultry 1999

24 Mercury in fish effect on nervous system development 2004

25 Mercury in childhood inoculations and autism 2005

26 Cell phone towers and cancer, etc. 2008

No comments:

Post a Comment